Why Was Aretha Franklin's Family Upset By The Eulogy?

Aretha Franklin's family expressed their disappointment in the eulogy delivered at her funeral, describing it as distasteful and offensive. Discover what caused the controversy and learn how to avoid similar issues in your own eulogy writing process.

The Controversy Behind Aretha Franklin's Eulogy

In August 2018, the world mourned the loss of the Queen of Soul, Aretha Franklin. Known for her legendary voice and unwavering civil rights activism, she left behind a lasting legacy. Friends, family, and fans gathered for her funeral, expecting to pay their respects and celebrate her life. However, the eulogy delivered by Reverend Jasper Williams Jr. caused an uproar, with many attendees and the Franklin family itself expressing disappointment and anger at its content.

What Was Wrong with the Eulogy?

While a eulogy should focus on the person's life, achievements and character, Reverend Williams' speech veered off course into divisive political and social commentary, barely mentioning Aretha Franklin or her contributions. Many found the remarks offensive and out of place for the solemn event. Some specific issues included:

• Lack of focus on Franklin's life and accomplishments
• Controversial comments on single mothers, African-American culture, and the Black Lives Matter movement
• Insensitive remarks about Franklin's family, particularly her children
• Using the eulogy as a platform for personal opinions rather than a tribute to the deceased

The Franklin family expressed their heartbreak in how their loved one was portrayed, stating that Reverend Williams' eulogy did not accurately represent Aretha or her beliefs.

How to Avoid Controversy and Disrespect in a Eulogy

When delivering a eulogy, you have the honor and responsibility of representing someone's life and legacy. Avoid repeating the mistakes made at Aretha Franklin's funeral by following these guidelines:

• Stay focused on the deceased: Keep the speech centered on the person's life, accomplishments, and character. Share personal anecdotes, memories, and their impact on those around them.
• Be respectful: If speaking on the behalf of the family, be mindful of their wishes and feelings. Don't bring up sensitive or controversial topics, especially without discussing it with them beforehand.
• Avoid personal opinions on political or social issues: While it's appropriate to mention the deceased's beliefs and affiliations, a eulogy is not a platform to promote your own views. Focus on how the deceased's beliefs shaped their life and actions instead.
• Keep the tone appropriate: A eulogy should be heartfelt, genuine, and respectful. Avoid negative comments, divisive statements or inappropriate jokes that can cause discomfort or offense.

Why Was Aretha Franklin's Family Upset By The Eulogy? Example:

Let's consider a revised version of Aretha Franklin's eulogy that avoids controversy and focuses on honoring her life:

Friends, family, and distinguished guests, we gather here today to celebrate the life and legacy of the great Aretha Franklin, the Queen of Soul. A woman of extraordinary talent, unwavering determination, and a compassionate heart, her music touched the lives of millions and continues to inspire future generations.

Aretha's journey started in Detroit, where she found solace in the songs of her father's church. Her unmistakable voice led her to international fame, but her values and her love for family and community remained steadfast. Alongside her incredible musical achievements, Aretha was a fierce advocate for civil rights and women's empowerment, using her fame as a force for change.

Aretha was more than just the Queen of Soul - she was a loving mother, a devoted friend, and an unwavering beacon of hope. Her memory will live on through her music, her activism, and the love she shared with everyone she encountered.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the main reason Aretha Franklin's family was upset by the eulogy?

Aretha Franklin's family was upset by the eulogy because they felt it was offensive and distasteful. The family expressed that the eulogist, Rev. Jasper Williams Jr., used the platform to deliver a speech that was more political than reflective of Aretha Franklin's life and legacy.

Who delivered the eulogy at Aretha Franklin's funeral?

The eulogy at Aretha Franklin's funeral was delivered by Rev. Jasper Williams Jr., a pastor from Atlanta who has a history with the Franklin family.

What specific elements of the eulogy were the Franklin family unhappy about?

The family took issue with Rev. Williams's comments on black lives matter, single mothers, and his view on what constitutes true respect for African American women. They felt these comments were inappropriate and not aligned with Aretha's values or the tone appropriate for a eulogy.

Did Rev. Jasper Williams Jr. have a personal connection to Aretha Franklin?

Yes, Rev. Jasper Williams Jr. had a personal connection to Aretha Franklin. He eulogized Aretha's father, Rev. C. L. Franklin, in 1984 and had known the family for many years.

Was the eulogy reflective of Aretha Franklin's wishes for her service?

According to statements from Aretha Franklin's family, the eulogy did not align with what they believe would have been her wishes. They expressed that the service was meant to honor her life and career but felt that the eulogy failed to appropriately do so.

Did any members of Aretha Franklin's family speak out publicly about the eulogy?

Yes, members of Aretha Franklin's family, including her nephew Vaughn Franklin, spoke out publicly expressing their disappointment with the nature of the eulogy.

How long was the eulogy delivered by Rev. Williams?

The eulogy delivered by Rev. Jasper Williams Jr. lasted for about 50 minutes, which is longer than typical for such remembrances.

What was the reaction of attendees during the eulogy?

Reports indicate that attendees showed mixed reactions during the eulogy. Some seemed upset or uncomfortable, while others listened quietly or showed support for the sentiments expressed by Rev. Williams.

Were any parts of the eulogy positively received?

While there was controversy, some may have found Rev. Williams's emphasis on the African American community and its challenges to be valuable, although this was overshadowed by the overall negative reception.

How did the eulogist respond to the backlash?

Rev. Williams defended his eulogy, stating that his intention was to highlight social issues affecting the black community and that he was sorry if he offended anyone, but stood by his message.

Was Aretha Franklin's funeral service broadcasted or televised?

Yes, Aretha Franklin's funeral service was broadcasted live on several television networks and streamed online.

Did the family expect the controversial nature of the eulogy beforehand?

It is unclear if the family expected the controversial nature of the eulogy beforehand. However, their public response indicates they were taken aback by the content and tone of Rev. Williams's address.

Did the family issue a formal statement regarding their feelings about the eulogy?

The family issued a formal statement through Aretha Franklin’s nephew, Vaughn Franklin, who expressed that the family found the eulogy to be distasteful and noted that it did not properly reflect Aretha Franklin's legacy.

What has been the public reaction to the family's statement?

The public reaction to the family's statement has been largely supportive, with many people expressing sympathy and agreeing that the eulogy was not appropriate for the occasion.

Were there other speakers at the funeral who spoke more favorably of Aretha Franklin?

Yes, the funeral included many other speakers, including friends, family members, and dignitaries, who spoke in more personal and favorable terms about Aretha Franklin's life, talent, and contributions.

Did Aretha Franklin leave specific instructions for her funeral arrangements?

While Aretha Franklin was known to be private about her personal life, it has not been publicly disclosed whether she left specific instructions for her funeral arrangements, including the choice of eulogist.

Has this kind of controversy over eulogies at celebrity funerals happened before?

Controversies over eulogies are not exclusive to Aretha Franklin's funeral; such occurrences have happened at other celebrity funerals, though they are relatively uncommon.

Has there been any outreach from faith leaders regarding the incident?

Several faith leaders have voiced their opinions on the matter, with some offering support to the family and others discussing the eulogy's appropriateness within the context of gospel ministries.

Following the controversy, will there be any additional memorials to honor Aretha Franklin?

While there may not be a formal event announced in direct response to the controversy, Aretha Franklin's legacy continues to be honored through various tributes and ongoing support for her music and philanthropy.

What measures can be taken in the future to prevent such a mismatch between a family's wishes and a eulogy's message?

To prevent such a mismatch, it's essential to have clear communication between the family and the person delivering the eulogy. It's also helpful to choose a eulogist who understands the family's wishes and the individual's legacy intimately.

Where can individuals go to learn more about Aretha Franklin's life and legacy?

Individuals interested in learning more about Aretha Franklin can explore various biographies, documentaries, and her extensive music catalog available online, in libraries, and through music platforms. Additionally, many museums and institutions dedicated to music history feature exhibits about her life.

It's crucial to craft a eulogy that not only honours the memory of your loved one, but also respects their values and the feelings of those attending the funeral. We hope that by exploring Aretha Franklin's eulogy controversy, you gain valuable insight into crafting a touching, respectful tribute. For more guidance on writing eulogies, we invite you to use Eulogy Assistant's funeral speech writing tool and explore our other helpful guides. Share this article to help others learn from this situation and create heartfelt eulogies for their loved ones.