Why is water cremation illegal? This concept may sound wacky and even absurd, but it’s a question that has been subject to increasing scrutiny as the world looks towards more eco-friendly alternatives to traditional burial and cremation methods.
Table of Contents
Understanding Water Cremation
Also known as alkaline hydrolysis or bio cremation, water cremation is a procedure that uses water and alkali to break down the body. The process imitates natural decomposition but at a far faster rate, typically a few hours. This method leaves behind bone ash, which is identical to what remains after a standard fire cremation and can then be returned to families.
The Benefits of Water Cremation
There are several advantages to water cremation that have led to growing interest in this alternative. Firstly, it uses less energy than traditional cremation, making it a more environmentally friendly option. It also has the benefit of producing less air pollution and a reduced carbon footprint. Another advantage is that medical implants, such as artificial hips or heart valves, can be recovered after the procedure and recycled.
The Legal Status
The legal status of water cremation varies by region, and this is where it gets tricky. Despite the obvious environmental benefits, water cremation is not yet legal in every state of America, let alone every country worldwide. Many places currently do not possess the pertinent laws to address such a procedure.
Why it is Illegal
Need a Eulogy?
Get a Personalized Professional Eulogy Written For Your Loved One
There are a few reasons as to why water cremation is still illegal in many parts of the world. Many people are simply not comfortable with the new concept, while others question the ethics of liquid disposal of human remains into the sewer system, albeit after it is safely processed and screened. Additionally, the technology for water cremation is still quite new, and the apparatus needed is often far more expensive than traditional cremation equipment.
Why Is Water Cremation Illegal Example:
As an illustration, the lessened public understanding of water cremation can be compared to the reception of traditional cremation when it was first introduced to Western societies. There was initial resistance due to religious and societal preconceptions, but with time it gradually gained acceptance. Similar transformation might occur for water cremation once its benefits and essence are better communicated and understood by the general public.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is water cremation?
Water cremation, also known as alkaline hydrolysis or aquamation, is an eco-friendly alternative to traditional flame cremation. It involves breaking down the body using an alkaline solution and water, which results in a sterile liquid and bone ash, which can be returned to the family similarly to cremated remains.
Why might water cremation be considered illegal?
Water cremation might be considered illegal in some places due to a lack of legislation that specifically addresses or permits the process, public health concerns, traditional values, environmental regulations, or pressure from industries that favor traditional burial and cremation methods.
Which countries have legalized water cremation?
Water cremation has been legalized in countries that are open to alternative disposition methods, such as Canada and the UK, albeit it is still regulated and not widely available. The legality can vary even within a country, depending on regional laws.
What are the main environmental concerns with traditional cremation?
Traditional cremation releases greenhouse gases and mercury emissions from dental amalgams into the atmosphere. It also consumes a significant amount of energy, contributing to its environmental footprint.
Is water cremation more environmentally friendly?
Yes, water cremation is considered more environmentally friendly due to its lower carbon footprint, reduced energy use, and the absence of direct emissions of mercury and other pollutants.
What happens to the liquid byproduct of water cremation?
The liquid byproduct is primarily water containing small amounts of salts and amino acids, which is typically neutralized and safely released into the sewage system, where it undergoes standard water treatment processes.
Can families still hold a funeral with water cremation?
Yes, families can still hold a funeral or memorial service with water cremation. The process of aquamation simply replaces the method of body disposition; all the traditional elements of a service can still be a part of the memorial.
How long does water cremation take?
Water cremation typically takes between 4 to 6 hours, which is comparable to the amount of time required for a flame cremation.
Are the remains from water cremation similar to those from flame cremation?
The remains from water cremation are similar in that they consist of bone ash, which can be processed into a fine powder and returned to the family. However, they are typically whiter and more consistent due to the nature of the process.
Is water cremation recognized by religious authorities?
Acceptance of water cremation by religious authorities varies. Some may accept it due to its gentle process and reduced environmental impact, while others may not yet recognize it due to tradition or other concerns.
Are there any health risks associated with water cremation?
Water cremation is considered a safe process with no significant health risks to the public. The resulting sterile liquid is treated like any other wastewater and the bone remains pose no risk of contamination or disease transmission.
Can all bodies be subjected to water cremation?
Most bodies can undergo water cremation, but certain medical devices, such as pacemakers, need to be removed beforehand to prevent reactions with the alkaline solution. Consultation with the water cremation provider is recommended to discuss any specific concerns.
What are the costs associated with water cremation?
The costs for water cremation can be comparable to or slightly higher than traditional cremation due to the specialized equipment required. Prices vary by provider, so it is essential to inquire with local services for precise figures.
Why is there resistance to water cremation?
Resistance to water cremation often stems from a lack of public awareness, discomfort with new methods of disposition, entrenched traditions, and economic interests of the funeral industry which may prefer conventional methods.
What is being done to legalize water cremation?
Proponents of water cremation are engaging in educational campaigns, legislative lobbying, and environmental advocacy to demonstrate the benefits of water cremation and encourage legal acceptance and regulation.
How does water cremation handle obese bodies?
Water cremation can generally handle bodies of various sizes. However, depending on the capacity of the equipment at the facility, there may be weight limits. It is best to consult with the aquamation provider for specific guidelines.
What are the major benefits of choosing water cremation?
Major benefits of water cremation include its environmental friendliness, its gentle process, which is less harsh than flame cremation, and the potential for cleaner and purer remains that are returned to the family.
Are there ethical considerations in choosing water cremation?
Individuals choosing water cremation may consider ethical factors such as environmental stewardship, personal values alignment, and the desire for a more natural process of body disposition.
What kind of containers can be used for the ashes from water cremation?
Just like with traditional cremation, the ashes from water cremation can be placed in a variety of containers including urns, boxes, or eco-friendly biodegradable options for those looking to continue the environmentally conscious theme.
Can water cremation be performed on pets?
Yes, water cremation is often available for pets as well. The process is similar to that used for humans and provides pet owners with an eco-friendly alternative to traditional pet cremation.
How can one find a water cremation facility?
One can find a water cremation facility by researching local funeral homes, crematories, and online directories. Some regions may have more providers than others due to varying legal statuses and public demand.
The legality of water cremation is undoubtedly a complex issue that will take time to address fully. As we continue to search for more environmentally friendly alternatives in all aspects of our lives, question like 'Why is water cremation illegal?', will play an essential part in fostering necessary dialogue to bring about change. Don’t forget to share this article with others who may be interested in these new and innovative end-of-life options. Explore other guides on Eulogy Assistant for more about honoring our beloved ones in environmentally friendly ways.